CO129-263 - Acting Governor Barker Governor Sir Robinson - 1894 [5-8] — Page 289

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Crown Colony, but it has thriven, it is not too much to say. The petitioners mention four colonies to which self-government limits have been conceded. They are Malta, Cyprus, Mauritius, British Honduras. Hongkong differs from all these. It is much smaller, it is much younger, has practically no history, no traditions, and no descendants of old colonists. It has no indigenous population, few permanent residents, and is an outpost in a foreign land, more like Gibraltar than either of the four dependencies mentioned above, though it is much less of a fortress and more of a trade emporium than Gibraltar.

Taking the claims which the petitioners have put forward. The first is Free election of representatives of British nationality in the Legislative Council. They look for an elected Assembly, they ask at the same time that only British nationality should be represented! The words are cleverly chosen. Do they mean that the electors may be of any nationality but that they are to elect only representatives of British nationality? In other words, may Chinamen vote as long as only Englishmen are elected?

Is British nationality synonymous with British Subjects, & does British Birth mean origin? The common sense meaning of the words is that the English residents in Hongkong shall elect representatives to the Legislative Council, and this is probably intended, though the framers of the petition can, if they will, put another construction on their phrase. If this is so, the petitioners ask for a chamber containing an elective element, to be elected on a franchise running along a very narrow line.

It has always seemed to me that the Constitutions of those Crown Colonies, which are not fully self-governing colonies, are the worst features in the English colonial system. They are

Edit History

2026-05-27 12:01:30 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Crown Colony, but it has thriven, it is not too much to say. The petitioners mention four colonies to which self-government limits have been conceded. They are Malta, Cyprus, Mauritius, British Honduras. Hongkong differs from all these. It is much smaller, it is much younger, has practically no history, no traditions, and no descendants of old colonists. It has no indigenous population, few permanent residents, and is an outpost in a foreign land, more like Gibraltar than either of the four dependencies mentioned above, though it is much less of a fortress and more of a trade emporium than Gibraltar. Taking the claims which the petitioners have put forward. The first is Free election of representatives of British nationality in the Legislative Council. They look for an elected Assembly, they ask at the same time that only British nationality should be represented! The words are cleverly chosen. Do they mean that the electors may be of any nationality but that they are to elect only representatives of British nationality? In other words, may Chinamen vote as long as only Englishmen are elected? Is British nationality synonymous with British Subjects, & does British Birth mean origin? The common sense meaning of the words is that the English residents in Hongkong shall elect representatives to the Legislative Council, and this is probably intended, though the framers of the petition can, if they will, put another construction on their phrase. If this is so, the petitioners ask for a chamber containing an elective element, to be elected on a franchise running along a very narrow line. It has always seemed to me that the Constitutions of those Crown Colonies, which are not fully self-governing colonies, are the worst features in the English colonial system. They are
Baseline (Original)
2 Crown Colmy, but it has thriven, it is not Too much to Crown Colony say. because it has been a petitioners mention The Which nights 1 government within mention four colmies to of 3 Solf government limits have been conceded. They are Malta, Cyprus, Mauritius, British Honduras Hongkong differs from all these. It is much smaller, it is much it has no hist younger, has practically no traditions it has · Чтобым of there have Colvicts of British Notimality bene firme and no descendants of och colorists No indigenons populating, ameachi your as it has few few permanent residente. foreign land, It is an outpost in a derhal like more Λ Gibraltar than either of the four dependencies mentioned above, though it is much less of a Ja fortress mole of a trade emporium thas Gibraltar Taking the claims which the petitionens have put forward. The first is Free election 9. Ze resentatives of British 9. Ze vresentatives of "nationality in the digisiative Council colony: of the They Took for an Get elected Assembly, they ask at the same time that e He only British no should be represented! The words are tionality an Spapternal prostir om Natives, беля 32 Me Joten Balls, D Cyprus Bull ponesi by a Or rather, to be accenate, for an Assembly with an elective element in it! +3 You Britüift & demöte (ich then are any) Patter cleverly chosen. Do they the electors may منا 286 mean that but of any nationality that they are to elect only representatives of of one. the British nationality other words as 1 may In Chinamen vold as long only Englishmen are elected? again Is British nationality synoxy. "mons with British Subjects, & does British Birth and it mean The common sense m meaning g rigin? the words is that the English residents in Hongkong, shall duct that a representatives to the on will degislation founcil, and this is probably intended, though the framers of the petition ean, if they will, put another construction on their phrase. If this is so the petitioners ask for containing an clutive clement, to be chamber elected on a A franchise, running along, a very: the line o an ramow lace. It has always seemed to me that the Constitutions ησι Of those pass Colonies. Which are. (Town Colonies and not fully Hilf governing colonies, are the worst features in the English colonial system. They are
2026-05-27 12:01:30 · Baseline
View content

2

Crown Colmy, but it has thriven, it is not

Too much to

Crown Colony

say.

because it has been a

petitioners mention

The Which

nights

1 government within

mention four colmies to of 3 Solf government limits have been conceded. They

are

Malta, Cyprus, Mauritius, British Honduras Hongkong differs from all these. It is

much smaller, it is much

it has no

hist

younger, has practically

no traditions

it has

·

Чтобым

of there have

Colvicts of British Notimality bene firme

and no descendants of och colorists

No indigenons populating, ameachi your as it has few

few permanent residente.

foreign land,

It is an outpost in a

derhal like

more

Λ

Gibraltar

than either of

the

four dependencies mentioned above,

though

it is much less of a

Ja fortress

mole of a trade emporium thas Gibraltar

Taking

the claims which the petitionens have put forward. The first is

Free election 9. Ze resentatives of British

9. Ze vresentatives of "nationality in the digisiative Council

colony:

of the

They Took for

an

Get

elected Assembly, they ask at the same time that e He only British no

should be represented! The words are

• tionality

an Spapternal prostir

om Natives,

беля

32 Me

Joten Balls,

D

Cyprus Bull ponesi by

a

Or rather, to be

accenate, for an

Assembly with an

elective element in it!

+3

You Britüift

& demöte (ich then

are any)

Patter cleverly chosen. Do they

the electors

may

منا

286 mean that

but

of any nationality

that they are to elect only representatives of

of one. the British nationality

other words

as

1

may

In

Chinamen vold as long

• only Englishmen are elected?

again

Is British nationality synoxy.

"mons with British Subjects, & does British Birth and

it mean

The

common sense m

meaning g

rigin?

the words

is that the English residents in Hongkong,

shall duct that

a representatives to the

on will degislation founcil, and this is probably

intended, though the framers of the petition ean, if they will, put another construction on their phrase. If this is so the petitioners ask for

containing an clutive clement, to be

chamber elected on a

A

franchise, running along,

a very: the line o

an

ramow

lace.

It has always seemed to me that the

Constitutions

ησι

Of those pass Colonies. Which are. (Town Colonies and not fully Hilf governing colonies, are the worst features

in the English colonial system. They

are

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.